Search
Leave a Message
By providing your contact information to Will Kennish’s team @thegrouprealestate, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Will Kennish’s team @thegrouprealestate's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you consent to receive communications regarding your real estate inquiries and related marketing and promotional updates in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Will Kennish’s team @thegrouprealestate at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe.
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Covered home entry with checked timber beams, taupe siding, gray stonework and golden aspen leaves in afternoon light.

Why Steamboat's No-Rental Red Zone Still Has Hundreds of Licensed Rentals

October 15, 2026

On Steamboat Springs' short-term rental overlay map, Zone C is labeled "prohibited." As of July 7, 2026, it also had 259 active short-term rental licenses.

Both are true, and the gap between them explains how rental value works in the Yellow and Red Zones. Almost every license in those two zones exists because a particular property held a rental right before the overlay took effect on June 15, 2022. Those rights stay with the property, nobody can create new ones, and each one can be lost. Since 2023, dozens of them have been terminated, and the code offers no way to restore one. In these zones the color on the map matters less than the paper trail behind one specific address.

What the 259 Red Zone licenses actually are

These figures come from the city's July 17, 2026 City Council retreat packet, which gives licensing data as of July 7, 2026. As of October 12, it is the newest official count by zone. It sorts every standard license by the right that supports it.

Overlay zone Cap Active licenses Prior VHR permit Legal nonconforming Pre-2022 timeshare Lottery
Zone A, green none 2,061 n/a n/a n/a n/a
Zone B, yellow 82 136 33 95 0 8
Zone C, red none 259 111 126 22 n/a

In Zone C, only three things make a property eligible: a Vacation Home Rental permit issued before the overlay, a short-term rental use registered as legal nonconforming, or a timeshare created before June 15, 2022. Zone B adds one more route, the license lottery, and that route accounts for just 8 of its 136 licenses.

The Green Zone has no legacy pool at all, since any property there can apply. That's also where the 553 units at The Steamboat Grand, One Steamboat Place and Sheraton Steamboat Resort Villas sit. The city exempts them from licensing because they have staffed 24-hour management, so they don't appear in the table.

The Yellow Zone cap is a ceiling the zone is already above

Zone B's cap is 82. On July 7, 2026, it held 136 licenses, roughly 166% of the cap. Every subzone was over its cap that day:

  • B1: 6 licenses against a cap of 5
  • B2: 23 against 20
  • B3: 23 against 18
  • B4: 43 against 17
  • B5: 23 against 12
  • B6: 18 against 10

The city code allows this on purpose. Zone B licenses "may exceed the caps" to accommodate legal nonconforming uses and permitted VHR uses, and no application from those owners "shall be denied on the basis of the limitations on license numbers."

The lottery runs on different rules. Under the licensing ordinance posted by the city, a waiting list only issues licenses when the number of available licenses in a subzone is greater than the number of legacy uses there. If more owners apply than there are openings, the director holds a lottery to set the order. After that, new requests join the list in the order they arrive.

Do that math for B4. With 43 active licenses and a cap of 17, the subzone would have to lose more than two dozen licenses before a single lottery license opened. So the waiting list doesn't move as demand changes. It moves only when legacy rights disappear, one property at a time.

Three ways a legacy right ends

Since the overlay was adopted, 266 properties registered as legal nonconforming short-term rentals. Six never got a license and lost the status. Of the 260 that did get licensed, 38 have had their status terminated since 2023 "due to abandonment of the STR use," and they are no longer eligible. Eighteen of those 38 were in Zone B and 20 were in Zone C.

The code provides at least three ways out:

  1. Non-use. When the program launched, the Steamboat Pilot & Today reported the city's explanation in 2022: if a property is not used as a short-term rental for 12 consecutive months, its legal nonconforming use "will terminate on the property permanently." The same article said VHR permit holders did not need to prove use or worry about losing their license for inactivity. The general nonconforming-use language in the Community Development Code is tighter. It lists six consecutive months for an abandoned or discontinued use, one season for a seasonal use, and twelve months for an intermittent use, "regardless of any intent to resume." Neither source says which category a short-term rental falls into. Until the city confirms which clock applies, anyone holding or buying one of these rights is working with an open question.

  2. A late renewal. Licenses expire one year after they're issued. Renewal requires the fee and a complete application filed at least 30 days before expiration. A renewal filed after the expiration date is denied, and the owner has to apply for a new license. In a capped Yellow subzone, that application goes to the waiting list. In Zone C, the code says "no new license may be issued." The city now sends reminders 60, 30 and 15 days before expiration, plus a notice once a license expires.

  3. An unused lottery license. Ordinance 3015, adopted August 5, 2025, says a Zone B license issued through the waiting list or lottery can only be renewed if a short-term rental use occurred during the prior license period.

None of these paths runs the other way. Under the standing rules, a terminated right doesn't return when a new owner wants to rent. The only exception on record is a one-time grace period that City Council created, covered below.

What actually changes hands at closing

Here the scarcity hits a buyer directly. Steamboat licenses are not transferable between people or locations. The code says that when a licensed property is transferred, "the new owner shall be required to apply for a new license." The eligibility underneath the license is a different matter. City staff told the Pilot in 2022 that legal nonconforming status "runs with the property, not the owner," so a buyer of a property with active status only needs to apply for a new license.

The volume is real. By April 8, 2026, the city had received 42 new license applications that year. Staff counted 20 as first-time rentals entering the market and reported 22 licenses issued because of property sales.

What transfers, then, is a right whose value depends on its history. In a Red or Yellow Zone property, the questions that shape a rental-minded offer are about that address:

  • Which right supports the current license: VHR, legal nonconforming, timeshare or lottery?
  • Has the property been used as a short-term rental recently enough to stay clear of either abandonment clock?
  • When does the license expire, and how does the closing date line up with the 30-day renewal window?
  • If it's a lottery license in Zone B, was there rental use during the current license period?

Two Red Zone condos with identical finishes can carry very different value depending on those answers. One has an eligibility path. The other may have lost its path for good.

The one time the count went up

The city has reopened the door once. Ordinance 3024, adopted September 16, 2025, gave owners in Zones B and C a 60-day grace period to apply if they had held a valid VHR permit on June 15, 2022 and either never got a license or got an initial license before April 30, 2023 and failed to renew it. Staff mailed notice to 25 qualifying owners, and 16 took the offer. That added 16 licenses across Zones B and C and pushed B1 and B2 over caps they had been held to until then.

The same packet shows enforcement moving in a gentler direction. Fines for unlicensed operation have been "substantially reduced," and some first-time offenders are offered a deferred judgment that avoids the two-year licensing ban.

So the rules are not frozen. The July 17, 2026 retreat agenda included a short-term rental discussion covering "Process/Penalties" and "STR Eligibility and Priorities." The records reviewed for this post don't show what direction, if any, came out of that discussion. The city's meeting calendar listed the next City Council meeting for October 13, 2026. Until something new is adopted, every right in Zones B and C follows the attrition rules above.

Quick answers

Can a Red Zone owner without a legacy right rent at all? In a limited way. Hosted licenses, which cover one guestroom of up to 400 square feet while the owner or another permanent resident is present, and temporary licenses, which allow a primary residence up to two occurrences and 30 cumulative days a year, are unlimited in every zone. On July 7, 2026, Zone C had 19 active hosted licenses and 15 temporary ones.

Has a Yellow Zone lottery license ever been issued? Yes. The July 2026 count lists eight, three in B1 and five in B2.

What does a license cost? The most recent published figure is $315 for 2025 licenses and renewals. A 2026 fee schedule wasn't located.

If you're looking at a Yellow or Red Zone property and rental income is part of the plan, the license history matters as much as the inspection report. Will Kennish can help you trace which right a property holds, how its renewal date lines up with your closing, and how a lapse would change the numbers. Then you can make your offer with clear eyes. Make the Move. Live the Dream.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Follow Us On Instagram